Interview questions that actually predict performance

Hiring Amara Osei 12 Nov 2026 6 min read
Interview questions that actually predict performance

Most interview questions reward confident storytelling. These five probe real working behaviour instead.

Interviews reward fluency. Fluency correlates weakly with performance, which is why so many confident hires stall in month three.

Ask for a past behaviour, then go one level deeper

Instead of asking how someone handles conflict, ask them to describe the last disagreement they had with a colleague and what they did the following day. Specificity is difficult to invent.

Use work that resembles the job

A short, paid work sample scored against a written rubric predicts first-year performance better than any set of hypothetical questions we have tested.

Separate evidence from impression

Ask each interviewer to submit scores before the debrief. Conversation is for clarification, not for consensus building.

Score consistently across candidates

Keep four criteria, define each at three levels, and revisit the definitions every quarter as the role evolves.

Close the loop

Every interviewed candidate deserves one specific sentence about their evidence. It costs two minutes and it is the difference between a brand and a rumour.

Ready to get started?

Tell us what you are hiring for, or what you want to do next. We reply to every request within one business day.